Cheap Car Insurance campare: Geico, Progressive and Esurance

This is just for "me" a student, less than 5 years with license. Geico had the highest for the lowest plan available for $455, Progressive was 253, Esurance was 175, however they required a down payment of 364.82 which when i called them they spread it out over the 4months. car was a 1996 ford mustang